fbpx The Founding of the Reconstructionist Rabbinical College | Reconstructing Judaism

The Founding of the Reconstructionist Rabbinical College

Article

This piece was originally commissioned by the Reconstructionist Rabbinical Association, which published a version of it in the Summer 2018 edition of  Connection, the association’s newsletter. Part II of this history will appear later this academic year in Reconstructing Judaism Today.

For more on RRC’s 50th anniversary, visit our 50th Anniversary Showcase at https://www.rrc.edu/50th.

Mordecai M. Kaplan affixing a mezuzah to the doorpost of the RRC campus at Broad Street during the dedication ceremony of the college, October 13, 1968.
Mordecai M. Kaplan affixing a mezuzah to the doorpost of the RRC campus at Broad Street during the dedication ceremony of the college, October 13, 1968.

The Reconstructionist Rabbinical College opened its doors in the fall of 1968. Its establishment was improbable for any number of reasons. Mordecai Kaplan, the founding thinker of the Reconstructionist movement, had long been on record as advancing Reconstructionism as a “school of thought” rather than as a separate denomination. Aspirations for the Reconstructionist movement consistently exceeded funding, and the prospect of raising resources to establish a graduate school seemed far-fetched. Serious planning for the seminary only began in 1966. However unlikely, RRC admitted its first students fifty years ago this year and continues to train rabbis in a Reconstructionist perspective.

The establishment of a dedicated Reconstructionist institution fulfilled Kaplan’s educational aspirations. He identified powerfully as an educator: Jewish education was the focus of the penultimate chapter of Judaism as a Civilization. In his 1936 book Judaism in Transition, he suggested a rabbinical training curriculum that would provide leadership training for a civilizational approach to Jewish life. Kaplan subsequently built on this leadership vision to propose a university of Judaism to  help American Jews build a rich and inclusive Jewish civilization based on  peoplehood, including it as the summative chapter of his 1948 Future of the American Jew. (Kaplan’s ultimate goal was for the Jewish Theological Seminary to be reorganized along these lines, but Conservative movement leaders adopted the name and the enthusiasm it garnered to establish a West Coast institution.)

Dedication ceremony for RRC on North Broad Street, 1968.
Dedication ceremony for RRC on North Broad Street, 1968.

Yet establishing any institution had to overcome Kaplan’s three decades of resistance to establishing a separate denomination. In part, he and his followers recognized the decline of Kaplan’s influence at the Jewish Theological Seminary of America and beyond. Though still widely respected, the 82-year old thinker was no longer the towering Jewish communal giant he was in the period preceding and immediately following the Second World War. Kaplan was also intensively frustrated by Zionism’s singular focus on the Jewish state following 1948. Throughout the 1950s, Kaplan expended significant energies trying to convince the World Zionist Organization to promote worldwide Jewish peoplehood. His lack of success led Kaplan to think differently about the roles of American Jewish institutions in fostering Jewish life. By 1959, Kaplan began to imagine a separate institution. He wrote to Abram Sachar, Brandeis University president proposing a “Research Institute for the Spiritual Unity and Functioning of the Jewish People,” and developing a plan for a Reconstructionist graduate school.

In the same period, the Reconstructionist movement was in the midst of significant changes. Many years of trying to convince the Conservative movement to adopt “unity in diversity”—a Kaplanian reworking of the United States motto—and recognize Reconstructionism as the left-wing of the Conservative movement was yielding only modest success. In 1959, the Jewish Reconstructionist Foundation was reorganized and Ira Eisenstein became president, with an agenda to promote Reconstructionism through institutions. This restructuring followed the 1955 establishment of a congregational union by four congregations. Joined by other congregations as well as newly forming havurot, congregational members met in 1959 to collaborate and agitate for resources and appropriately trained leaders. At the 1963 convening of the Federation of Reconstructionist Congregations and Havurot, there was “a long heart-to-heart talk about the movement and its future.” Kaplan was so inspired by this convening — or so pressured by his disciples — that he penned his letter of resignation from JTS, enabling plans for an educational institution to advance.

Mordecai M. Kaplan teaching at RRC.
Mordecai M. Kaplan teaching at RRC.

A heart attack in 1964 temporarily limited Eisenstein’s capacities. Late in 1966, the Foundation board committed to serious exploration of establishing a leadership training program. A planning committee was convened, and Eisenstein made a modest announcement in the spring Reconstructionist newsletter. The 1967 FRCH Convention powered forward the idea of a training institution. The Federation passed the following resolution on June 1, 1967:

Whereas the future of the Reconstructionist movement will be strengthened by the availability of rabbis and teachers properly educated and trained and imbued with the spirit of Reconstructionist philosophy, be it RESOLVED that the Federation of Reconstructionist Congregations and Fellowships recommends to the Jewish Reconstructionist Foundation the establishment of a school for the training of rabbis and teachers…

Worried about the financial burden of an independent educational institution, the planning committee investigated burgeoning Jewish studies programs at secular universities and considered establishing a cooperative program. Arthur Gilbert, a Reform-trained rabbi with long ties to the Reconstructionist movement, was hired to take primary responsibility for moving the initiative forward. Gilbert focused on partnering with established Jewish studies programs, while Eisenstein worked on building up support, financial and otherwise, and responding to criticism that with this move Reconstructionism was betraying its commitment to avoid divisiveness and promote collaboration.

RRC students discussing the Talmud, 1995. From left to right: Rabbi Jamie Arnold, RRC '99; Rabbi Jodie Siff, RRC '01; Rabbi Jeremy Schwartz, RRC '97 and Rabbi Myriam Klotz, RRC '99. Photographer: Scott D. Weiner.
RRC students discussing the Talmud, 1995. From left to right: Rabbi Jamie Arnold, RRC ‘99; Rabbi Jodie Siff, RRC ‘01; Rabbi Jeremy Schwartz, RRC ‘97 and Rabbi Myriam Klotz, RRC ‘99. Photographer: Scott D. Weiner.

By late fall 1967, Gilbert had approached several universities, finding Temple University to be the most enthusiastic. In 1965, Temple had shuttered its seminary, become a state-related university, and was expanding its religion department. The Foundation board authorized Gilbert to begin negotiations and by January 1968, Gilbert recommended proceeding. Prospective rabbinical students would apply for admission as graduate students at Temple, and if admitted would be accepted by the Reconstructionists. Rabbinical students would be expected to complete a Ph.D. in Jewish studies at Temple and pursue additional coursework to make them eligible for the title of rabbi. Eisenstein reviewed plans for obtaining a temporary charter from the Commonwealth, assembling an advisory council to form the faculty, renting appropriate space and raising adequate funds. While the Commonwealth required assets of at least $500,000 for a permanent charter, $50,000/year for three years would enable the launch. Pledges of $116,000 were made at the meeting and a national fundraising drive was announced. The board voted to move forward.

The news and details were announced to the wider Reconstructionist world in a February 1968 editorial in The Reconstructionist. The editors rejoiced, “This will be the first time that the Reconstructionist philosophy will be taught not as a separate subject but as the pervading approach to all subjects.” A somewhat rundown building located near both Temple University and Dropsie College was purchased for $25,000, and a supporter provided funds to purchase basic furniture. Kaplan and Rabbi Max Schenk donated their libraries to establish the school’s library. Eisenstein and Gilbert began generating a curriculum reflecting the evolving religious civilization based on Kaplan’s chapter on rabbinic training from Judaism in Transition. Kaplan vigorously refused Eisenstein’s entreaties that the school be named after him, though he assented to the library being named in his honor. While spring announcements referred to “the Reconstructionist Rabbinical School,” by fall “Reconstructionist Rabbinical College” was formalized.

RRC students and faculty sitting on bench, c. 1999. From left to right: Rabbi Myriam Klotz, RRC '99; Marjorie Lehman, Ph.D. and Rabbi Nancy Epstein, RRC '06.
RRC students and faculty sitting on bench, c. 1999. From left to right: Rabbi Myriam Klotz, RRC ‘99; Marjorie Lehman, Ph.D. and Rabbi Nancy Epstein, RRC ‘06.

To recruit students, the Foundation circulated a large poster to all Hillel Foundations; reached out to T’hiyah, the Reconstructionist college program; and recruited among the children of long-time supporters and readers of The Reconstructionist. These strategies — and the draft for the Vietnam War — created a robust initial class of 13 students. Eisenstein reflected in the 1980s that many of the early applicants were quite radical, questioning all inherited values and concepts. Most eventually dropped out, with only two ultimately completing the program. One potential applicant was a woman. Eisenstein wrote to her: “I gather from your name that you are a woman and therefore I hesitate to send you an application form or other materials dealing with our school. While we have every intention ultimately to consider favorably the admission of women into our rabbinical training course, we are not prepared to do so at this time.” The reluctance was resolved within the first year as Sandy Eisensberg entered with the second class. When she graduated, Sandy was the second American woman to become a rabbi and, with her marriage to classmate Dennis Sasso, they became the first rabbinic couple in history.

Graduating rabbis, class of 1974. Back row, from left to right: David Brusin, Saul Perlmutter, Kenneth Berger and Moshe Birnbaum. Front row, from left to right: Steven Stroiman, Sandy Eisenberg Sasso, Dennis C. Sasso and Aaron Peller.
Graduating rabbis, class of 1974. Back row, from left to right: David Brusin, Saul Perlmutter, Kenneth Berger and Moshe Birnbaum. Front row, from left to right: Steven Stroiman, Sandy Eisenberg Sasso, Dennis C. Sasso and Aaron Peller.

The College was dedicated on Sunday, October 13, 1968, on Hoshanah Rabbah. The formal ceremony took place on Temple’s campus. Speakers included Eisenstein, the founding president; Dr. Bernard Phillips, chair of Temple’s Religion Department; the president of Lancaster Theological Seminary on behalf of the American Association of Theological Schools; and Abraham Goodman on behalf of the Jewish Reconstructionist Foundation board. Arthur Gilbert was acknowledged for his monumental efforts to establish the College and celebrated as the founding dean. He read telegrams from Jewish and Christian seminaries and introduced each of the new rabbinical students and faculty members. Kaplan gave the major address. The guests then walked with lulavim and a banner to the new RRC building. They chanted verses from Hallel, Kaplan affixed the mezuzah and everyone in attendance recited the blessing and shehekyiyanu. Classes began the following day.

The founding of RRC provided a cadre of leaders for the Reconstructionist movement and beyond, with more than 350 rabbis serving congregations, on campus, as educators, organizational leaders, chaplains and entrepreneurs. The College has served as the incubator for such influential programs as the Shalom Center, Shomrei Adamah, Moving Traditions and Ritualwell.org, and as the creative source for the Kol Haneshamah prayer book series and the Guide to Jewish Practice. Even as many of the challenges present at the founding persist, the 2012 merger between the College and the congregational union presents opportunities for further influence and expansion of a Reconstructionist approach.

Graduating rabbis, class of 2018. From left to right: Sandra Lawson, Emily Cohen, Jacob Adler, Ariana Katz, Nathan Kamesar, Jessica Rosenberg, David Eber and Elyssa Cherney.
Graduating rabbis, class of 2018. From left to right: Sandra Lawson, Emily Cohen, Jacob Adler, Ariana Katz, Nathan Kamesar, Jessica Rosenberg, David Eber and Elyssa Cherney.

Part II of this history will appear later this academic year in Reconstructing Judaism Today. Part II will concern the implications of the founding of the College and the continuities and discontinuities of the current moment.

For more on RRC’s 50th anniversary, visit our 50th Anniversary Showcase at https://www.rrc.edu/50th

President and CEO, Reconstructing Judaism; Aaron and Marjorie Ziegelman Presidential Professor, Reconstructionist Rabbinical College

Related Resources

News and Blogs

Reconstructionists Featured at Society for Jewish Ethics Conference

The Reconstructionist movement is being well represented at the 2022 Annual Meeting of the Society of Jewish Ethics, taking place Jan. 6-9 over Zoom. In fact, in terms of the number of presenters —at least three — the movement will have a greater presence at this year’s virtual gathering than at any time since the first conference was held in 2003.

News

God in Metaphor: A Guide for the Perplexed

Rabbi Toba Spitzer explores the obstacles to prayer posed by stale language about God, and suggests new language that may ease our way in finding connection.

Article
News and Blogs

New Online Community for Jewish Poets and Liturgists Aims to Produce “Ripple” Effect

For 20 years, Ritualwell has served as a pioneering resource for original Jewish liturgy and rituals, along the way nurturing an informal network of liturgists, poets and ritual innovators. Now, it has launched ADVOT @ Ritualwell, a formal online community offering unprecedented support and empowerment to writers who are imagining new ways to mark life’s most salient moments in a Jewish context.

News
News and Blogs

The "Next Normal" and Our Movement

The last sixteen months of the pandemic have highlighted the necessity of community as something both poignant and urgent.  With many of us physically removed from our “normal” sites of gathering (i.e., workplaces, schools, cultural venues, “third spaces,” places of worship), we’ve learned to cultivate relationships online, to use digital tools to create new places of meeting and connection, and to experiment with alternative and even more accessible forms of engagement.  Despite the very real challenges of long-term isolation and Zoom fatigue, we’ve found new ways to experience community, to address pragmatic needs, and to fill our souls.

News
News and Blogs

America's First Bat Mitzvah and its Legacy for American Jewish Life

The first American bat mitzvah took place nearly a century ago, but its effects reverberate to this day. This podcast episode explores how the bat mitzvah helped pave the way for greater inclusion of women in public Jewish ritual and practice and laid the groundwork for further steps toward inclusion.

News
News and Blogs

Rooted and Relevant: 21st Century Jewish Life

In her presentiation, Rooted and Relevant: 21st Century Jewish Life, Rabbi Deborah Waxman, Ph.D., explores how Reconstructionist Judaism can lead the way in the post-COVID world toward a religious revival that meets this century’s new realities. 

News
News and Blogs

Collaboration Across Difference: An Innovation Power Tool

This article was originally published in eJewish Philanthropy on Nov. 25, 2019.

News
News and Blogs

Provide for Yourself a Rabbi

If we are serious about building Jewish community, what could be more important than educating, nurturing and supporting Jewish leaders — rabbis — who will partner with us, teach us, learn with us, and both ground us in our tradition and inspire us to reach for new meaning?

News

Divine Justice: A Jewish Perspective

Rabbi Deborah Waxman, Ph.D. spoke at the Chautaqua Insitution about divine justice, about good and evil and about God’s presence, plans, and love in the face of what seems to be unearned suffering. 

Article
News and Blogs

New Book Sparks Conversation Between Torah, Kaplan and Real Life

A Year With Mordecai Kaplan: Wisdom on the Weekly Torah Portion by Rabbi Steven Carr Reuben, Ph.D. is a deeply rooted and boldly relevant Torah commentary. For each week’s reading, Rabbi Reuben weaves together traditional commentary, a nugget of Mordecai Kaplan’s thought, and a vivid personal insight that illuminates the connection between the two. This powerful and accessible work invites us to engage with Torah, Kaplan and contemporary human experience in ways that are nourishing, optimistic and inspiring.

News

Session 5: Questions and Answers

Audience questions and answers at Reconstructing Jewish Communities panel

Article

Session 4: The Need to Wrestle with Difficult Issues

Rabbi Shira Stutman on Reconstructing Jewish Communities panel

Article

Session 3: The Need to Reconstruct Judaism Itself

Rabbi Michael Strassfeld on Reconstructing Jewish Communities panel

Article

Session 2: Redeveloping Congregational Identity So That Being Part Of The Congregation Makes Meaning

Rabbi Lauren Grabelle Herrmann on Reconstructing Jewish Communities panel

Article

Session 1: The Need for Progressive Jewish Communities to Reconstruct Themselves in This Era

Rabbi Sid Schwarz introducing Reconstructing Jewish Communities panel

Article