fbpx Reclaiming Judaism After Centuries Underground | Page 3 | Reconstructing Judaism

Reclaiming Judaism After Centuries Underground


The mountain town of Serrastretta in the Calabria region of southern Italy is not an obvious place to find a synagogue, let alone a Reconstructionist one. But beneath the Catholic surface of this remote community lies a surprising Jewish legacy: Many families are descended from b’nei anusim, Jews who underwent forced conversion to Catholicism during the Inquisition. Their synagogue, Sinagoga Ner Tamid del Sud, affiliated with Reconstructing Judaism in 2017. Although their rabbi, Rabbi Barbara Aiello, grew up in Pittsburgh, her father’s family originated in Serrastretta. For Rabbi Barbara’s grandmother, Judaism was something practiced only in secret: Shabbat candles were lit behind shuttered windows or in the basement, out of sight of the neighbors, and her father was sent to a neighboring town to learn Torah.

When Rabbi Barbara returned to live in her ancestral village in 2004, she found similar stories of secret Jewish practice. And Jewish roots were often kept secret even within families. She relates numerous stories of deathbed revelations by elderly men and women, who as their final act told their astonished families the real reason for unusual family customs: “We’re Jewish.”

Such remnants of hidden Jewish practice kept cropping up. When she went to the home of a neighbor whose mother had died, she found the mirrors covered, chairs removed and a plate of hard-boiled eggs on the table — “our family tradition,” the neighbor told her, unaware of any commonality with Jewish mourning practices. Other local customs included throwing out eggs with bloodspots, holding special meals for 12-year-old girls and getting married sotto la coperta (“underneath the bedspread”) echoing a traditional Jewish wedding canopy.

Since starting Sinagoga Ner Tamid del Sud and its sister organization, the Italian Jewish Cultural Center of Calabria, Rabbi Barbara finds that people approach the possibility of Jewish heritage in a variety of ways. Many are simply curious about their roots and intrigued to know the origin of family traditions. But others are drawn not only to explore, but to embrace their Jewishness. Reconstructionist Judaism offers a welcoming model for these seekers and learners. It is an inclusive non-Orthodox Judaism that welcomes those of all backgrounds and stages of exploration. Those values drew Sinagoga Ner Tamid del Sud to join Reconstructing Judaism as an affiliate.

The Reconstructionist approach to Jewish tradition affirms that Judaism grows and evolves in every generation. This spirit is evident in the community’s innovative way to officially welcome back those who wish to claim formal Jewish status through conversion. Rabbi Barbara created a unique document to accompany a standard conversion certificate: Recononscimento dello Status di Ebreo/a, a formal recognition of Jewish status. Crafted to address the emotional and spiritual needs of a community with a long history of trauma, this certificate embodies a Reconstructionist affirmation of the power of Jewish peoplehood and of a conscious transformation of traditional conversion ritual to address unique historical needs.

Written in Italian and English, the document reads, in part:

“This document represents the recognition of your Jewish roots that were stolen from your ancestors. We recognize that your ancestors were Jews but during times of persecution such as the Inquisition in Spain, Portugal, Sicily and Italy there were forced conversions where anusim families lost their Jewish religion and Jewish traditions …You have found and embraced your Jewish roots, you have studied the Jewish religion and have made the commitment to live as a Jew with love of Torah and the Jewish people. Your Jewish family says to you, ‘Welcome Home.’”

Certificate of Jewish status in English and Italian


Interim Rabbi, Temple Beth-El of Poughkeepsie

Related Resources

"Where Was God?" - Lesson Plan On Natural Disasters and Parashat Noah

During disasters and their aftermaths, many people wonder about God’s role in their suffering. This lesson seeks to explore God’s role in tragedy from a Jewish Reconstructionist perspective. This lesson is intended for children ages 8-12.


How Can Reconstructionists Pray?

How does a non-supernatural notion of God fit together with the practice of prayer? Rabbi Jacob Staub explores their intersection. 

News and Blogs

Nothing Neutral About It: Inspired by Reconstructionist Judaism in Switzerland

Paul Piwnicki, a Polish-born, German-raised scientist and Jew-by-choice, credits Reconstructionist thought with helping him develop a personal theology and practice. Piwnicki’s story highlights the influence of Reconstructionist ideas and thinkers, even in countries lacking Reconstructionist congregations.


If God Is Good, Why Do Pain and Suffering Exist?

The question is an old and venerable one: If God is good, and God is all-knowing, and God is all-powerful, then why is there so much pain and suffering in the world? Rabbi Jacob Staub explores this longstanding question. 

News and Blogs

Light Through The Cracks

Rabbi Deborah Waxman reflects on finding spiritual equilibrium in a time of shifting sands.


Liturgy and Prayer Leadership: Distance Learning Session

This distance learning conference call explores the dynamics of worship and the human impulse to pray, some of the deep structures of Jewish prayer services, and specifically Reconstructionist liturgy.

Spoken Audio

Kaplan and the Meaning of Ritual: Reconciling the Mind and the Heart

The author reflects on the way Mordecai Kaplan's philosophy  helped him see Jewish ritual as spiritually meaningful and, at the same time, intellectually honest.


Author Interview: Guide to Jewish Practice

Interview with Rabbi David Teutsch, Ph.D., about the issues addressed in the new Guide to Jewish Practice


Reconstructionism Explained

What is Reconstructionist Judaism? Its essence is contained in the phrase, “Judaism is the evolving religious civilization of the Jewish people.” Unpacking this phrase, we find five simple keys to understanding the philosophy and beliefs of Reconstructionist Judaism.


A Hasidic Lens on Parashat Bo

In this short talk, Rabbi Lester Bronstein brings 18th and 19th-century Hasidic thought into dialogue with contemporary Reconstructionist theology.

Spoken Audio

A New Approach to the Rules Shaping Shabbat Practice

Congregation B’nai Israel in Willimantic, Connecticut underwent a long communal Reconstructionist process to decide on congregational rules for Shabbat practice. This is the result.


Yigdal: A Reconstructionist Examination

Yigdal, one of the most beloved of the medieval piyyutim (liturgical poems) summarizes the thirteen principles of the Jewish faith as formulated by Moses Maimonides (RaMBaM; late 12th century C.E.). Reconstructionists often proudly assert that when we pray with a Reconstructionist siddur, we feel that we can 'say what we mean and mean what we say,' because our liturgical language reflects Reconstructionist theology. How might a Reconstructionist interpret the words of Yigdal in this way?


Exploration of God Beliefs: A Teen Program

This pilot program for Jewish teen education provides several activities for exploring and sharing beliefs about God. 


A Child's Biography of Mordecai Kaplan

This short biography of Mordecai Kaplan is written for children from 5th to 9th grade.


For The Sake Of The World

Rabbi Toba Spitzer grapples wtih the traditional notion of Jewish chosenness, arguing that our Torah is integral to the maintenance and perfection of this world—even as we acknowledge that other people’s teachings, other people’s truths, are also a path to redemption. It matters that  Judaism survives—not just for our own sake, but because it’s good for the world, and because we have unique work to do.