fbpx Jewish-Muslim Relations in America: How to Be an Ally | Reconstructing Judaism

Jewish-Muslim Relations in America: How to Be an Ally


Note: This piece was published in January, 2016. 

The author can be contacted by email at Nfuchs-kreimer@rrc.edu.

Educate yourself.

This is step number one. It is absolutely exhausting for Muslims to have to personally educate each non-Muslim they meet. (Jews in largely non Jewish areas complain of the same problem vis a vis Christians.) It is not terrible to ask an openhearted, curious question of a Muslim that is really “google-able,” but when it comes to the common misunderstandings, it is better to do some of our own work first.

  1. Familiarize yourself with the 10 things most Americans “know” about Islam that are not true.
  2. Follow young Muslim thought leaders (e.g. Haroon Moghul, Abdullah Antepli, Reza Aslan, Wajahat Ali, Rabia Chaudrey, Homayra Ziad, Najeeba Syeed) on their blogs, Twitter or Facebook pages.
  3. Read! You can start with Rabbi Reuven Firestone’s An Introduction to Islam for Jews. Other good introductions include No god but God by Reza Aslan and Memories of Muhammad by Omid Safi.
  4. After learning a bit about Islam, a next step would be to familiarize yourself with issues between Muslims and Jews in our country. Muslims and Jews in America edited by Reza Aslan and Aaron Hahn Tapper is a great start, especially the article by Rabbi Amy Eilberg.
  5. Essential Reading: Center for American Progress’ report on the roots of the Islamophobia network in America, Fear, Inc.
  6. To gain understanding of the Muslim American realities today, read a few novels or plays by Muslim Americans (e.g. Wajahat Ali’s Domestic Crusaders, Mohja Kahf’s Girl in the Tangerine Scarf) or memoirs (e.g. The Butterfly Mosque by Willow Wilson or Acts of Faith by Eboo Patel) or watch films (e.g. New Muslim Cool or Unmosqued)

Build Relationships

This is the essential next step, where the education comes to life and you can begin to really grow your understanding.

  1. Befriend local Muslims, through local mosques or college/university MSA’s.
  2. Join or Start a Daughters of Abraham Women’s Interfaith Book Group or a chapter of Sisterhood of Salaam Shalom (or create male equivalents)
  3. Help to start an interfaith program for teens and let the teens’ friendships lead to relationships on the adult level. Check out Walking the Walk as a model.
  4. Get ideas for relationship building from the resource guide Sharing the Well, available as a pdf online.

Be an Agent of Cultural Change

  1. Invite local Muslim leaders or scholars to come and teach your folks about Islam.
  2. Introduce connections and narrative migration between Islamic and Jewish cultures in your teaching (e.g. Stories of Joseph: Narrative Migrations between Judaism and Islam)
  3. Attend fundraisers for CAIR or local mosques with interested congregants.
  4. Help create interfaith events (e.g. concerts, peace walksSpread Humus not Hate), world travel)
  5. Work on long term issues of concern for both communities through Multifaith organizations engaged in justice work (e.g. PECO).

Take Action

  1. Find out about flashpoint causes of concern to Muslims when they arise in your community (e.g. bus ads, zoning battles, surveillance issues). Call your friends (see #2) and ask how you can help. 
  2. Write letters to the editor to the Jewish and general press
  3. Show up for rallies; bring other Jews with you.
  4. For guidance on best practices, contact the Shoulder–to–Shoulder Campaign of the Islamic Society of North America or T’ruah –the Rabbinic Call for Human Rights — or New Ground: A Muslim-Jewish Partnership of Change
Former Director, Department of Multifaith Studies and Initiatives; Associate Professor Emeritus of Religious Studies, Reconstructionist Rabbinical College

Related Resources

Being the Stranger

It takes work to avoid being strangers to one another.


Looking Backward and Looking Forward: Texts for a Jewish Resistance Movement

These materials explore Jewish models of resistance to oppression. 


The Midwives of Exodus: An Interfaith Text Study

An easily-accessible text study about the ethnic ambiguity that the Torah presents us with regarding the midwives who refused to obey Pharaoh's orders. 


Guide to Free Media Publicity

The goal of this document is to provide synagogues with guidance regarding how to obtain publicity that will enhance their outreach efforts.


Reconstructionism, Chosenness, and the Abrahamic Dialogue

Fuchs-Kreimer describes how respect for interfaith colleagues led her to re-examine Jewish beliefs she once dismissed out of hand. 


How to Build Just and Holy Congregations

Tepperman encourages sustained congregational dialogue and action around social, environmental and political justice.

News and Blogs

Voters Must Act Against Demagoguery

RRC President Rabbi Deborah Waxman, Ph.D., was among the 18,000 people in the audience for Donald Trump’s March 21 speech to the AIPAC Policy Conference. Her response was published in The Philadelphia Inquirer  under the title “Voters Must Act Against Demagoguery.” 


Take Your Judaism For A Walk

A short parable on being out and about in the world

News and Blogs

Twelve Things I Learned About Islam and Muslim Americans

In this essay from the spring of 2015, Rabbi Nancy Fuchs-Kreimer shares her initial misconceptions about Islam and what she’s learned since. She is Director for Multifaith Studies and Initiatives at the Reconstructionist Rabbinical College.